• Practices

  • Selected Expertise

    • Antitrust damages assessment
    • Applied econometrics
    • Auctions
    • Collusion
    • Game theory
    • Industrial organization
  • Selected Industries

    • Construction
    • Dairy
    • Government procurement
    • Jewelry
    • Packaging
    • Pulp and paper
    • Semiconductors
    • Timber
    • Vitamins

ROBERT C. MARSHALL, PhD

Partner

Robert C. Marshall is a Partner at Bates White and, in addition, Liberal Arts Research Professor, Head of the Department of Economics, and co-Director of the Center for the Study of Auctions, Procurements, and Competition Policy at The Pennsylvania State University. Dr. Marshall is a recognized thought leader in the areas of industrial organization, collusion, applied game theory, auctions, and procurements. He has served as a testifying expert in major antitrust litigation matters, with particular expertise in antitrust liability and cartels.

Dr. Marshall has testified before Congress regarding incentives in procurement contracting and he has published extensively. His articles and papers in peer-reviewed journals and elsewhere include topics on collusive mechanisms, detecting bidder collusion, differential payments within a bidder coalition, and incentives in procurement contracting. A recent paper, “Plus Factors in Agreements in Antitrust Law” (Michigan Law Review, December 2011, with Kovacic, Marx, and White,) won the Jerry S. Cohen Memorial Fund Writing Award for best antitrust scholarship of 2011. In addition, Dr. Marshall has recently published a book, coauthored with Leslie M. Marx, entitled The Economics of Collusion: Cartels and Bidding Rings (MIT Press, 2012). He has served on two panels for the National Research Council and he is on the editorial board of the Journal of Antitrust Enforcement.  

Selected Experience

  • Provided liability expert report and deposition testimony for several direct and indirect plaintiffs in In re Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) Antitrust Litigation.
  • Provided expert report and deposition testimony in an analysis of class certification issues in In re Ready-Mixed Concrete Antitrust Litigation. Analysis examined suitability of class-wide treatment. Critically assessed assertions made by plaintiffs′ economic expert.
  • Provided liability expert report and deposition testimony for a large coalition of direct-action plaintiffs involved in a complex horizontal conspiracy matter in In re Linerboard Antitrust Litigation.
  • Submitted declaration regarding the allocation of settlement funds and the pass-through of price increases for diamonds in Sullivan v. DB Investments.
  • Provided liability expert report and deposition testimony regarding the existence of collusive behavior on behalf of more than 100 direct action plaintiffs in In re Vitamins Antitrust Litigation.
  • Provided expert report and deposition testimony regarding an auction of a professional sports franchise, working on behalf of the US Department of Justice, Tax Division.
  • Performed general game theory instruction for a consortium of telecommunication bidders interested in bidding for FCC spectrum.

Education

PhD, Economics, University of California, San Diego

AB, Economics, Princeton University

  • Practices

  • Expertise

    • Antitrust damages assessment
    • Applied econometrics
    • Auctions
    • Collusion
    • Game theory
    • Industrial organization
  • Industries

    • Construction
    • Dairy
    • Government procurement
    • Jewelry
    • Packaging
    • Pulp and paper
    • Semiconductors
    • Timber
    • Vitamins

Insight

  • 21 June 2012

    Bates White partners win prestigious Jerry S. Cohen Memorial Fund Writing Award

  • April 2012

    “The Economics of Collusion” by Robert Marshall and Leslie Marx

  • December 2011

    “Plus Factors and Agreement in Antitrust Law” by William E. Kovacic, Robert C. Marshall, Leslie M. Marx, and Halbert L. White

  • December 2009

    “Quantitative Analysis of Coordinated Effects” by Robert Marshall, Leslie Marx, and Steve Schulenberg, Antitrust Law Journal

  • Summer 2009

    “Cartels as Two-Stage Mechanisms” by Randal Heeb, Robert Marshall, and Leslie Marx, Chicago Journal of International Law

  • May 2009

    “The Vulnerability of Auctions to Bidder Collusion” by Robert Marshall and Leslie Marx, Quarterly Journal of Economics

  • March 2007

    “Bidder Collusion” by Robert Marshall and Leslie Marx, Journal of Economic Theory

  • 2007

    “Lessons for Competition Policy from the Vitamins Cartel” by W. Kovacic, R. Marshall, L. Marx, and M. Raiff, The Political Economy of Antitrust

  • October 2007

    “Bidding rings and the design of anti-collusive measures for auctions and procurements” by W. Kovacic, R. Marshall, L. Marx, and M. Raiff

  • August 2006

    “Coordinated Effects in Merger Review: Quantifying the Payoffs from Collusion” by W. Kovacic, R. Marshall, L. Marx, and S. Schulenberg

  • Spring 2006

    “The Measurement of Economic Damages in Antitrust Civil Litigation,” H. White, R. Marshall, and P. Kennedy, Antitrust Law Economics Newsletter

  • January 2006

    “The Impact of Delivery Synergies on Bidding in the Georgia School Milk Market” by R. Marshall, M. Raiff, J. Richard, and S. Schulenberg

At the Podium

  • 12 June 2013

    Robert Marshall participates in American Antitrust Institute’s 14th Annual Conference

  • 1 May 2013

    Webinar: Detecting Cartels and Collusive Behavior

  • 14 March 2013

    Robert Marshall participates in Symposium on Competition and Procurement 

  • 27 November 2012

    Leslie Marx and Robert Marshall present “Cartel versus Merger” at DOJ Fall Seminar Series

  • 23–24 September 2011

    Robert Marshall and Michael Whinston speak at Northwestern Law′s Fourth Annual Antitrust Economics and Competition Policy Symposium

  • 8 June 2011

    Bates White partners and affiliates participate in DOJ Economic Analysis Group’s seminar series

  • 25 June 2007

    Bates White′s Fourth Annual Antitrust Conference

  • 26 September 2006

    Robert Marshall presents at FTC/DOJ hearing on single-firm conduct and Section 2 of the Sherman Act

  • 7–8 September 2006

    Robert Marshall speaks on anticollusion measures at LSI’s International Cartels Seminar

  • 6 September 2006

    Robert Marshall speaks on postmerger collusion at Fordham Competition Law Institute’s annual conference

  • 17–18 February 2005

    Robert Marshall, Leslie Marx, and Matthew Raiff speak at Remedies and Sanctions Competition Policy Conference in Amsterdam