Enforcement in labor collusion and monopsony: trends and challenges
Concerns about worker treatment were historically handled through labor and employment law, not antitrust law. But over the last fifteen years, U.S. antitrust agencies have increasingly focused enforcement on labor markets. Specific attention has been paid to labor collusion (wage-fixing and no-poach agreements) and monopsony issues (where proposed mergers could give employers excessive power in labor markets). In “Enforcement in labor collusion and monopsony: trends and challenges,” Leyla Karakas and Anna Meyendorff examine these areas of antitrust enforcement—including past developments, future trajectories, and notable obstacles.
Looking back, Drs. Karakas and Meyendorff discuss key moments that increased labor market scrutiny: the 2010 High-Tech Employee Litigation, the 2023 Merger Guidelines, Penguin Random House’s attempted acquisition of Simon & Schuster, and the Kroger–Albertsons merger. Going forward, the authors predict enforcement will rely on two parallel approaches: continued prosecution of wage-fixing and no poach agreements, and more aggressive review of mergers that may increase concentration in labor markets. However, monopsony-based merger challenges face substantial challenges: defining labor-markets and applying the SSNIP test is difficult, regulators have few widely accepted economic tools for forecasting how mergers will affect compensation, and there is limited evidence that labor-market concentration consistently has adverse wage effects across industries.
Because of these obstacles, the authors stress the value of merger-related analysis to inform agencies’ labor market focus. As economic research evolves, they foresee accelerated monopsony enforcement.
Read the article here (subscription required).
- Manager
- Partner